On Wednesday night Toby and I dressed up in our finest* and walked over to Tilth for a very exciting dinner.
*That is, a homemade dress for me and a pseudo-suit for Toby. Tilth is actually a very casual restaurant; we might have been the dressiest people there.
We’d already decided to get the vegetarian tasting menu with wine pairings, so we didn’t look at the menu too much — it was more exciting to be surprised with each of the five little courses. That our long-awaited Tilth meal took place in September was by design; since Tilth has a highly seasonal menu, we figured we’d get the most delicious haul of food at the end of the summer.
Just to warn you, the rest of this post is a detailed description of our entire meal.
Right away our server gave us a cute little amuse-bouche. It was a spoonful of cold sweet corn soup with a basil sauce on top. It was neat.
The first course was a cold cucumber soup, which came with a truly incredible piece of poppyseed tuile. The tuile was essentially a really buttery, thin, crispy cookie. The soup was really neat; it tasted like pure, smooth, rich essence of cucumber. There was also some dill for garnish. The wine pairing was a dry, sort of mineral-y Spanish white wine. I wasn’t sure if I liked the wine when I first sipped it, but it actually did go really well with the cucumber soup. The soup somehow made the mineral flavor less overwhelming. I began to believe in wine pairings.
The next course was really inspiring. It was a salad, made of feta cheese and two kinds of melon. There were watermelon rounds at the bottom, on the plate, and there was a cute little pile of a green melon (“French melon”?) with feta on top. There were also a bunch of salt crystals scattered throughout. I really adored the idea of a cheese-and-melon salad. I had never considered such a combination, and it was lovely! The wine was a much fruitier white wine that was easy to like.
Next we moved into the warmer main courses. First up was an amazing risotto, full of carrots, escarole, and pine nuts. It had a shocking amount of flavor: Toby and I discussed how we think of risotto as a sort of bland, rich dish to bury bitter things like beet greens into, but this risotto was no resting place for beet greens. I really want to make a flavorful risotto now. The wine was a delicious white wine that seemed to be a little bit fizzy.
The last dinner course might have been my favorite, but it’s hard to pick. (I loved them all, but I think this one and the melon salad stand out to me.) It was a bowl of small, incredibly creamy ricotta ravioli. The sauce had parmesan cheese, chanterelles, truffles, and cauliflower, and it was incredibly lemony. Wow, this one was good. It was paired with a wine I liked a lot, a pinot noir from Burgundy.
Finally, dessert! Dessert was a cute little white corn crème brûlée. It was rich yet corny at once, with a lovely crust of burnt sugar. There was a bit of fried hominy (weird! but good!) and a little smear of a delicious, yogurty-tasting corn creme on the side. But the real highlight of dessert was the wine pairing. It came with a Madeira wine, which is a Portuguese fortified wine (and possibly a subset of “port”; I don’t really know the distinctions).
Specifically, this one:
It was a really shocking beverage; I had never had anything like it. It tasted strongly of raisins and chocolate. It was incredibly delicious. We both can’t stop thinking about it. Highly recommended!
When our server brought the check, she included two tiny cardamom cookies with fruit filling. They were adorable and looked precisely like super-miniature Fig Newtons.
In summary, the tasting menu is amazing and is almost certainly the best way to enjoy Tilth. My feeling on the vegetarian vs. non-vegetarian tasting menu is that vegetarian food at nice restaurants tends to be more adventurous, so that menu is probably more exciting. (They are actually very similar, though; only two courses are different, and I’m sure the meat courses are delicious too. It’s Tilth, after all!) The wine pairings are neat and definitely recommendable. Tilth is a place to go for a really special dinner, and obviously we aren’t going to be doing this very often at all, but it’s very much worth it for a rare, incredibly exciting meal.
By the way, in case you’re curious (we were), the way wine pairings work (at Tilth anyway) is you get a half glass of the selected wine with each course. This works out to 2.5 glasses total for the 5-course menu, which was much more than I wanted, so I asked for small pours. I think I got about a glass and a half (and maybe slightly more) in total, which was nice.